Chicago Sun-Times publishes the Council's letter on "extraordinary rendition" -- the outsourcing of torture

March 1, 2005

On March 1, 2005, the Chicago Sun-Times published a letter, prepared by Gordon G. Waldron for the Council's Civil Liberties Committee, that sets forth the Council's position on "extraordinary rendition" -- the outsourcing of torture:

The Chicago Council of Lawyers calls on Congress to bar the United States from seizing persons and sending them to foreign countries where they are likely to be tortured. It further calls on Congress to bar the use of any U.S. funds for such purposes. The government has attempted to keep secret this practice, called ''extraordinary rendition,'' but recent media reports in the Washington Post, New York Times, Newsweek and New Yorker magazine have made it public.

Here's one example. In September 2002 Maher Arar, a Canadian citizen, was seized while in transit to Canada through JFK airport and sent to Syria at the request of the CIA. While in Syria Arar was tortured for about a year. Syria later released him, finding he had no link to terrorist activities, and he has returned to Canada and filed a suit against the United States. The United States has moved to dismiss the case, claiming it would force it to reveal ''secrets'' about national security.

Another example, involving persons seized outside the United States: In December 2001, two Egyptian men seeking political asylum in Sweden were seized in Stockholm and forced onto a jet (apparently owned by a CIA front) and flown to Egypt. Both say they were tortured while in Egyptian custody. One was convicted by an Egyptian military court of terrorism-related charges. The other was set free.

The Chicago Council of Lawyers believes that this practice already violates the Convention Against Torture, which the United States has ratified. Rep. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) has introduced legislation that would prohibit the United States from sending persons to countries that the State Department has certified commonly practice torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment during detention and interrogation. The Council calls on Senators Dick Durbin and Barack Obama and congresspersons from the Chicago area to support this bill. It also calls on Congress to pass legislation that would bar the use of any U.S. funds for such activities.

The Chicago Council of Lawyers believes that rejecting the outsourcing of torture will not only demonstrate our respect for the rule of law, but will reaffirm the fundamental principle that abetting torture is not acceptable under any circumstances.

Gordon G. Waldron
member, Civil Liberties Committee
Chicago Council of Lawyers