Waiting Game: Ryan Verdict Stakeout Gets Hectic on False Alarm

By Mike Ramsey
Copley News Service


10 April 2006

CHICAGO - The north elevator lobby of the 21st floor at Chicago's federal courthouse is nicknamed "Camp Ryan," and it got unusually full Thursday.

Reporters and producers waiting on a verdict in the racketeering trial of former Gov. George Ryan congregate in the windowed nook, which has rows of upholstered steel benches. The spot - resembling a mini-airport terminal - is prime real estate to gawk at jurors as they arrive or emerge from a back hallway to take breaks or to go home for the day.

Things have come to a virtual standstill after weeks of the closed-door deliberations. To help kill time, members of the media read books such as "Helter Skelter," "Manhunt" and "The Blood Knot." They tell jokes of questionable taste, quiz each other about details in the Ryan case and occasionally play cards or Scrabble. They bring in pungent carryout dinners from places like Chicken Planet and La Cocina and eat from their laps. A trash canister overflows.

Back to Thursday. Some observers noted that two of the women jurors showed up that morning dressed very nicely - an indication, perhaps, that a verdict was imminent. The speculation leaked onto a Chicago news radio station, and a jury consultant was interviewed (yes, the expert agreed, jurors tend to dress nicely on verdict day because of all the attention). The buzz was on: A verdict was imminent that day.

The Chicago papers sent in reinforcements, and additional television crews set up in the main courthouse entrance. Would Ryan and his businessman friend, Larry Warner, be convicted or acquitted of corruption charges? The media stood ready to break the news.

Then, at 11 a.m., one of the other women jurors was seen clad in a tank top, jeans and sneakers - hardly someone ready for her close-up.

Hours passed, hopes faded. At 4 p.m., a crowd of journalists watched the jurors trickle out to leave for a three-day weekend. Thankfully, though, the six-man, six-woman jury left a note to the trial judge asking for a witness transcript. Reporters could actually report on something.

For another perspective about the jury stakeout that never ends, check out "Trial of the Century?" the blog of NBC5 reporter Phil Rogers, at www.nbc5.com/news/4995704/detail.html.

Mistrial happens... in another case

U.S. District Judge Rebecca Pallmeyer, who is overseeing the Ryan case, declared a mistrial last week - in another trial.

This one, a drug-conspiracy trial, ended shortly after it began. Pallmeyer called a halt to the proceedings Tuesday after a prosecutor improperly told jurors that one of four defendants had spent time behind bars. She hoped to move ahead with a new jury, but defense attorneys decided to petition the appellate court upstairs in hopes of getting the charges dismissed.

In March, Pallmeyer flirted with the idea of ending the six- month Ryan trial after two jurors were found to have lied about their backgrounds. Instead, she replaced them with two alternate jurors and ordered the reconstituted jury to start fresh.

PALLMEYER PRAISED

The 51-year-old Pallmeyer, a University of Chicago Law School alum, got high marks in an evaluation released last week by the Chicago Council of Lawyers.

"Judge Pallmeyer is considered to be very smart, to understand complex matters, and to have an excellent temperament," the council, which surveyed attorneys, said.

But some lawyers offered "comments regarding (her) indecisiveness," the evaluation said. "These lawyers indicated that she can take time to make a decision and sometimes changes her mind after further argument."

The new chief judge of the federal district in Chicago, James Holderman, did not fare so well. The council assessed that Holderman, who had a well-publicized spat with the U.S. attorney's office in 2004, has good legal abilities but has exhibited temper flare-ups in court.

The council said Holderman promised to "keep a copy (of the evaluation) in my desk as a daily reminder of where I can improve." He assumes his leadership post this summer.

LOOKING AHEAD

The Ryan jury is expected to return today to the Everett M. Dirksen U.S. Courthouse. The revamped panel has deliberated for six days so far.

Copyright © 2006, Copley News Service.